DeHaan Painting’s Top 4 Interior Paints: A Side-by-Side Comparison

When it comes to interior painting, not all paints are created equal. At DeHaan Painting, we’ve worked with the best products on the market and have narrowed down our top picks to four premium paints that deliver durability, coverage, and performance. Whether you’re painting a high-traffic hallway, a kid’s playroom, or a refined living space, here’s our take on Sherwin-Williams Duration Home, Sherwin-Williams Scuff Tuff, Benjamin Moore Regal, and Benjamin Moore Scuff-X—so you can choose the right one for your home.

Sherwin-Williams Duration Home

Best for: Everyday durability in high-traffic areas
Finish Options: Flat, Matte, Satin, Semi-Gloss
MSRP: $60-$70 per gallon
Key Benefits:
✅ Washable and Stain-Resistant – Designed to resist stains and dirt, making it perfect for busy households.
✅ Moisture-Resistant – A great option for kitchens, bathrooms, and laundry rooms where humidity is a concern.
✅ Advanced Hide Technology – Covers imperfections with fewer coats compared to other paints.

Cons:
❌ Higher Cost – More expensive than standard paints, but you get what you pay for.
❌ Longer Dry Time – Takes longer to cure fully than other premium paints.

DeHaan Painting’s Take:
If you want a high-quality interior paint that holds up well over time and offers excellent washability, Duration Home is a solid choice. It provides a rich, smooth finish that stands up to everyday wear and tear. This is our STANDARD offering for a high quality paint at a reasonable price point from a trusted brand!

Sherwin-Williams Scuff Tuff

Best for: High-traffic areas like hallways, staircases, and mudrooms
Finish Options: Flat, Matte, Eg-Shel, Semi-Gloss
MSRP: $60-$70 per gallon
Key Benefits:
✅ Superior Scuff Resistance – Designed specifically to resist scuffs, scratches, and wear marks.
✅ Low Sheen for a Subtle Look – Available in Flat, Matte, AND Eg-Shel. Gives walls a modern, clean look without being too glossy.
✅ Ideal for Commercial and Residential Use – A great choice for homes with kids, pets, or heavy foot traffic.

Cons:
❌ Not as Moisture Resistant – Less moisture resistant than Duration.
❌ Less Smooth Application – Can require additional coats for full coverage.

DeHaan Painting’s Take:
Scuff Tuff is a fantastic option for homeowners who want a paint that can take a beating. Whether it’s from backpacks rubbing against the walls or frequent cleaning, this paint holds up exceptionally well.

Benjamin Moore Regal Select

Best for: Classic interior spaces with a luxurious, long-lasting finish
Finish Options: Flat, Matte, Eggshell, Satin, Semi-Gloss
MSRP: $65-$75 per gallon
Key Benefits:
✅ Smooth Application & Excellent Coverage – Fewer coats needed to achieve a flawless finish.
✅ Durable & Washable – Ideal for living rooms, bedrooms, and high-use areas.

✅Wide Selection of Sheens –
✅ Low VOC, Environmentally Friendly – A safer option for indoor air quality.

Cons:
❌ Not as Scuff-Resistant as Scuff-X – While durable, it doesn’t hold up to high traffic as well as some alternatives.
❌ Slightly Less Washable than Duration in lower sheens– Can require more effort to remove stains in high-traffic areas in Flat and Matte

DeHaan Painting’s Take:
Regal Select is one of the most trusted premium paints for homeowners who want a timeless look with a smooth, elegant finish. It’s easy to work with and provides great depth of color.

Benjamin Moore Scuff-X

Best for: The toughest, highest-traffic areas in homes and commercial spaces
Finish Options: Matte, Eggshell, Satin, Semi-Gloss
MSRP: $70-$80 per gallon
Key Benefits:
✅ Unmatched Scuff and Scratch Resistance – Designed for extreme durability in high-wear environments.
✅ Self-Leveling for a Professional Finish – Reduces brush and roller marks for a smooth look.
✅ Fast Drying & Low Odor – Convenient for quick turnaround projects.

Cons:
❌ Higher Price Point – The most expensive option on this list.
❌ More Difficult to Touch Up – Can be harder to blend seamlessly for small repairs.

DeHaan Painting’s Take:
Scuff-X is a game-changer for homes that see a lot of activity. If you want the toughest paint available without compromising on style, this is our top pick. It’s commonly used in commercial spaces but works wonders in high-traffic homes.

Final Thoughts: Which Paint is Right for You?

• For overall durability, & moisture resistance: Sherwin-Williams Duration Home
• For scuff-resistant, low-sheen finish: Sherwin-Williams Scuff Tuff
• For a classic, luxurious interior finish: Benjamin Moore Regal Select
• For the toughest, longest-lasting protection: Benjamin Moore Scuff-X

Helping Thousands of Families in Plaza Midwood, Noda, Chantilly, Dilworth, Elizabeth, Myers Park, South Park, Barclay Downs and Surrounding Areas.

DeHaan Painting
“Charlotte’s Premier Painter”

Dock, Deck, Fence Staining – Interior House Painting – Exterior House Painting – Kitchen Cabinet Painting – Limewash Applications – Commercial Painting – Christmas Light Installer

Phone: (980) 224-3191
Email: info@dehaanpaints.com