Latex Acrylic Vs Water-Based Polyurethane on Kitchen Cabinets

When it comes to giving your kitchen cabinets a fresh and vibrant look, two popular options often come to mind: latex acrylic paint (often used as trim paint) and water-based polyurethane (commonly known as cabinet paint and/or lacquer). Both have their own set of advantages and considerations, making the choice a crucial one for homeowners looking to update their kitchen. Let’s explore the pros and cons of each to help you decide which is the right choice for your kitchen cabinets.  For example, acrylic latex trim paint (Sherwin Williams Emerald) vs water-based polyurethane cabinet paint (Renner, Icro, Gemini, etc).

Latex Acrylic Paint for Cabinets

Latex acrylic paint (ex. Acrylic latex trim paint – Sherwin Williams Emerald) is a versatile option for cabinet makeovers. It offers a smooth finish and a variety of color choices, making it ideal for homeowners who want to update their kitchen’s look with a fresh coat of paint. Here are some key benefits of using latex acrylic paint for your cabinets:

1. Color Options: Latex acrylic paint comes in an extensive range of colors, allowing you to customize your kitchen cabinets to your preferred aesthetic.
2. Ease of Application: This type of paint is relatively easy to work with. It dries to the touch within 3-4 hours and can be sanded down 24-72 hours after application. This makes it a DIY friendly option for those who are brave enough to take it on!
3. Affordability: Latex acrylic paint is often more budget-friendly than some specialty cabinet paints, making it an economical choice for those looking to refresh their kitchen on a tight budget.

However, there are some considerations when using latex acrylic paint on cabinets. It can take up to 60-90 days to cure and might not provide the same level of durability and protection as cabinet-specific paints, which can be a drawback in a high-traffic area like the kitchen.

Water-Based Polyurethane for Cabinets

Water-based polyurethane paint (ex. Renner, Icro, Gemini, etc,) the preferred paint for cabinet finishers, is another option to consider. It is known for its exceptional durability and protection against wear and tear. Here are some reasons why you might choose water-based polyurethane for your cabinets:

1. Durability: Water-based polyurethane provides a tough, durable finish that can withstand daily kitchen use, including moisture, heat, and cleaning.
2. Easy Maintenance: Cabinets painted with water-based polyurethane are easy to clean and maintain. They are less likely to show signs of wear over time.
3. Smooth Finish: Water-based polyurethane provides a smooth, satin, or glossy finish that adds a touch of elegance to your kitchen.

Nonetheless, there are some downsides to using water-based polyurethane. It tends to be more expensive than latex acrylic paint, and the color options are slightly limited. While pretty much any color can be made for water-based polyurethane paint, it will always be considered a “custom match.” Additionally, water-based polyurethane is very difficult to roll on and works better as a spray, making this option less DIY friendly than latex acrylic paint.

Cost Analysis

When it comes to cabinet projects, using the right materials can make a world of difference. Consider this: to ensure a high-quality finish, water-based polyurethane costs about 10% of the overall material cost, compared to latex acrylic’s 5%. To put that into perspective, for a $5,000 cabinet job water-based polyurethane will cost you about $500, while latex acrylic will cost about $250.

Now, here’s where the cost-effectiveness becomes clear. The $250 savings seem appealing at first, but the advantages of using water-based polyurethane far outweigh the savings. Water-based polyurethane is created specifically for cabinets– resisting hand oils, kitchen grease, and chemicals. In comparison, latex acrylic can fall short. Its finish tends to be sticky, making it susceptible to nail marks and other forms of damage. Moreover, it requires a significantly longer curing time, spanning 60-90 days compared to the 20-30 days needed for water-based polyurethane. That’s a considerably longer time to exercise caution around your freshly painted cabinets.

In conclusion, the choice between latex acrylic paint and water-based polyurethane for your cabinets depends on your priorities. If you’re looking for a DIY and budget-friendly update, latex acrylic paint can be a suitable choice. However, if you want durability and long-lasting beauty for your cabinets, water-based polyurethane is the way to go. Consider the condition of your cabinets, your budget, and your desired aesthetic to make the best decision for your kitchen makeover!

Helping Thousands of Families in Plaza Midwood, Noda, Chantilly, Dilworth, Elizabeth, Myers Park, South Park, Barclay Downs and Surrounding Areas.

DeHaan Painting
“Charlotte’s Premier Painter”

Interior House Painting – Exterior House Painting – Kitchen Cabinet Painting – Limewash Applications – Commercial Painting – Christmas Light Installer

Phone: (980) 224-3191

Email: info@dehaanpaints.com